After the Oscars®  2005 - Hollywood Gold in Black & White

by Edward X. Young
To contact the movie critic email: exyoung@exyoung.com

 More film reviews and Oscar© commentary

Comedian Chris Rock, the host of the 77th Annual Academy Awards, shocked Academy members before the broadcast of the awards show by publicly declaring, "I never watched the Oscars," and dismissed the entire ceremony as idiotic.

Reputedly some Academy members privately called for Chris Rock (star of the HBO comedy special, CHRIS ROCK: BIGGER & BLACKER) to be removed as this year's host fearing the incendiary comedian had tarnished the reputation of the Oscars® when, during a pre-Oscar
® interview in early February of 2005, Rock said, "Awards for art are (expletive deleted) idiotic," and then added, "Come on, it's a fashion show!”

Chris Rock (pictured right) may have had a point, considering that nearly all the media coverage before and after the award show focused on almost nothing but who wore what designed by whom.  After all, isn’t the event supposed to be about Awards for Merit in the Motion Picture Arts and Sciences? 

Nevertheless, in spite of all the silliness and overblown pomp and circumstances, Oscar® merits legitimate praise – not only for ostensibly recognizing outstanding cinematic achievement – but also as a tool that has helped to shatter racial barriers and promote universal brotherhood.

Chris Rock’s rage is understandable, considering that there was once a time (and not too long ago) when the Oscar® show was as white as rice – and whenever on that rare occasion that an African-American performer received an Oscar® nod, everyone assumed that it was just a token nomination – and took it as axiomatic that the black nominee had no chance in hell of actually winning.

This, however, was not the fault of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences (AMPAS), the organization that oversees the Oscars® and presents the awards.  Rather it was symptomatic of a disgraceful time when America was torn by accepted racist values and segregation.  And that is not to say that things are perfect now.  But the times they are a changing …

To their credit, AMPAS has historically worked to change things for the better.

In 1939, actress Hattie McDaniel (pictured left), who played Mammy in the screen classic GONE WITH THE WIND, was denied admittance to the “whites only” premier of the film at a theatre in Atlanta, Georgia. Yet the following year, AMPAS presented the Oscar® for Best Performance by an Actress in a Supporting Role to McDaniel for her work on that film.  McDaniel was not only the first African-American to win an Oscar®, she was also the first African-American to attend the Academy Awards as a guest and not a servant.

In the years that followed, nominations and honorary Oscar® recognition for black artists were few and far between.  And it was a long time coming before Sidney Poitier became the next black actor to win a competitive Oscar® for Best Actor of the Year in 1963 for his performance in LILIES OF THE FIELD (pictured right). But Hollywood studios are not to blame for this cultural lacuna. You must remember that movies are an expensive art form and a risky commercial venture.  If Hollywood once displayed an unwillingness to provide meaty roles for black actors, it is only because the studio heads were worried about the green.  Movie executives were fearful that black artists would not draw box office returns from white Americans.

But AMPAS, through their continued recognition of the contributions of talented black artists (and other artists of color and ethnic and cultural diversity), has consistently worked to open the minds of mainstream American filmgoers and open doors for film artists, who are people of color.  And for that Oscar® deserves his own award.

Three years ago, in 2002, the Oscars® made front page headlines when for the first time in the history of the Academy Awards, the two top acting awards for Best Actor and Best Actress (pictured left) both went to artists of African-American descent.  Denzel Washington won for his riveting performance of a good cop gone bad in TRAINING DAY; and Halle Berry won for her heart-rending and unforgettable role as a woman who loses her son in a hit and run accident and her husband to capital punishment in MONSTERS’ BALL.  In their Oscar® acceptance speeches, both artists, acknowledged the cultural significance of the evening.  In particular, Halle Berry delivered a tearful tribute to the late Dorothy Dandridge, a woman Berry once portrayed in a TV biopic for HBO.  It should be noted that Dandridge, the first black actress to receive an Oscar® nomination for Best Actress for her performance in CARMEN JONES (1954) had to fight against racism and prejudice every step of the way along the rocky road of her career – and this unending struggle ultimately drove Dandridge into an early grave.

This year, black performers also won two of the top awards.  Jamie Foxx was named Best Actor of the Year for his portrayal of the legendary musician Ray Charles in the biopic RAY; and Morgan Freeman (pictured right) was honored as Best Actor in a Supporting Role for his performance as the half-blind ex-boxer, Scrap, in MILLION DOLLAR BABY.  In addition, more black artists were nominated for Oscars® in 2005 than in any previous year.  In the four Oscar® categories for acting, five of the nominations were for black actors.  Furthermore in the category for Best Documentary feature, TUPAC: RESURRECTION, a portrait of the black rap musician was nominated.  This year, in contrast to the Oscars® of 2002, in the winners’ acceptance speeches, race was hardly mentioned.  Freeman simply thanked Clint Eastwood for giving him a great role.  Jamie Foxx (pictured left) briefly acknowledged a debt to and influence from Sidney Poitier – and then delivered a tearful and unforgettable tribute to his loving grandmother who raised him to be the man he is today.

In addition, this year the Oscars® also made history in recognizing Spanish language performances.  For the first time, a Columbian Actress, Catalina Sandino Moreno was nominated for Best Actress of the Year for a Spanish-speaking role in the Columbian feature about drug-runners, MARIA FULL OF GRACE.  And for the first time, the Oscar® for Best Song went to a song that was sung in Spanish:  “Al Otro Lado Del Rio” from THE MOTORCYCLE DIARIES.

It’s amusing to look at the contrast to see how much things have changed.  Less than four decades ago, a nation was shocked when a white actor, William Shatner (as Captain Kirk) kissed a black actress Nichelle Nichols (as Lieutenant Uhura) on a primetime TV episode of STAR TREK (pictured left).  Two years ago, on the Academy Awards® broadcast (pictured right), an overly exuberant Adrien Brody, who won the Oscar® for Best Actor for his performance in Roman Polanski’s THE PIANIST, planted a wet one on the unsuspecting Oscar® presenter Halle Berry – and Halle Berry was the only one who was shocked.

No one can say that Oscar® has not helped to foster this greater spirit of brotherhood, tolerance, and multi-cultural harmony.  I’m sure Chris Rock would agree.

And the Winner is… all of us.

 

(Back to Top)

More film reviews
More Oscar Commentary

 


Site launched:  03/13/2002   Site updated:  01/17/2007

Site design by exyoung.com - Please contact exyoung.com for more information.

EXYoung.com Copyright Notice

©2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007 EXYoung.com, EdwardXYoung.com  All rights reserved.

The law provides that original materials such as writings, software, music, works of art, films and photographs are subject to copyright protection and may not be copied by others without the permission of the creator or copyright owner. The entire contents of this Web site are protected under one or more copyrights.

Click exyoung@exyoung.com here to e-mail your request to use any material on this site.